Why structure changes the price
In a stock purchase, the buyer steps into the company's existing tax basis. If the business is worth $10 million but its assets have a tax basis of $2 million, the buyer inherits the $2 million, and the other $8 million can't be deducted.
In an asset purchase, the buyer's basis is the price paid, allocated across the assets. Equipment can be depreciated, under the 2025 tax law often 100% in the first year. Goodwill and other intangibles are amortized over 15 years. Those deductions are real cash, and they're why a buyer will pay more for a step-up.
The trouble is that an asset sale is harder to close. Every contract, lease, license and permit has to be assigned, and some can't be. The three structures below solve that problem: a stock sale for legal purposes, an asset sale for tax purposes.
The three structures, side by side
| Question | 338(h)(10) election | 336(e) election | F reorganization |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | A joint election that treats a stock purchase as an asset purchase for tax | A similar election, made by the seller, that doesn't need a corporate buyer | A pre-sale restructuring; the buyer then buys LLC interests, which is an asset purchase for tax |
| Who can buy | A corporation only | Any buyer | Any buyer |
| How much must be bought | At least 80% within 12 months | At least 80% within 12 months | Any percentage |
| Step-up for the buyer | Yes | Yes | Yes, on the portion purchased |
| Seller's rollover equity | Treated as sold; taxed now | Treated as sold; taxed now | Can be structured to defer tax |
| If the S election was invalid | Election fails; buyer owns a C corporation and its history | Election fails | Buyer is protected; the old entity's history stays behind |
| Paperwork | Form 8023, filed jointly by a deadline | Written agreement and election statement with the return | New holding company, QSub election, conversion to an LLC before closing |
General rules for an S corporation target. Each deal turns on its own facts.
The 338(h)(10) election
The buyer and the S corporation's shareholders jointly elect to treat the stock purchase as if the company sold all its assets and then liquidated. The buyer gets the step-up, and the company stays the same legal entity, with its contracts and licenses intact.
- The buyer must be a corporation. Individuals, partnerships and most private equity fund structures can't use it directly.
- At least 80% must be purchased within 12 months. If private equity wants only 50%, it's off the table.
- The deadline is firm. Form 8023 is due by the 15th day of the ninth month after the month the deal closes. Missing it means asking the IRS for relief.
- Rollover is taxed. The seller's retained shares are treated as sold too, so there's no deferral on rolled equity.
The 336(e) election
The 336(e) gives a similar result when the buyer isn't a corporation. The S corporation and its shareholders make the election, and the buyer can be an individual, a partnership or a fund. It shares the 338(h)(10)'s main limits: 80% or more must be sold within 12 months, rolled equity is taxed, and the election is only as good as the company's S status.
The F reorganization
An F reorganization is, in the tax code's words, a "mere change in identity, form, or place of organization" of a corporation. Done before the sale, it lets the buyer purchase LLC interests instead of stock.
- The owners form a new corporation (NewCo), which elects S status.
- They contribute their shares in the operating company (OldCo) to NewCo, and NewCo elects to treat OldCo as a qualified subchapter S subsidiary (QSub).
- OldCo converts to a single-member LLC under state law. It keeps its contracts, licenses and bank accounts.
- The buyer purchases LLC interests from NewCo. For tax, that's a purchase of assets, so the buyer gets the step-up.
Why buyers prefer it:
- Any buyer, any percentage. A 60% purchase with the family keeping 40% works.
- Rollover can be tax-deferred. The seller can roll part of the value into the buyer's structure without paying tax on it now.
- Protection against a bad S election. If a past mistake, such as a non-pro-rata distribution or an ineligible shareholder, quietly ended the S election years ago, a 338(h)(10) fails and the buyer inherits a C corporation's tax exposure. In an F reorganization, that history stays with NewCo, the seller's entity.
A worked example
An S corporation sells for $10,000,000. The tax basis of its assets is $2,000,000, so a step-up adds $8,000,000 of basis. The buyer allocates it as follows (illustrative figures; the tax rate is assumed at 30%):
| Step-up allocated to | Amount ($) | How it's deducted | Year-one deduction ($) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Equipment | 1,500,000 | 100% bonus depreciation | 1,500,000 |
| Goodwill and intangibles | 6,500,000 | Amortized over 15 years | 433,333 |
| Total step-up | 8,000,000 | 1,933,333 |
At a 30% rate, the step-up saves the buyer about $580,000 of tax in year one and about $2,400,000 over the life of the deductions. In a plain stock purchase, the buyer gets none of it.
The seller's side. A deemed asset sale can cost the seller more than a stock sale. The gain on equipment is taxed largely as ordinary income through depreciation recapture, instead of at capital gains rates, and a company that converted from a C corporation within the last five years may owe built-in gains tax. The fair answer is often a gross-up: the buyer pays the seller part of the step-up's value to cover the extra tax. Both sides should model the deal after tax before agreeing on a price.
Which one fits?
- A corporate buyer buying 100%, with a clean S history: a 338(h)(10) is simple and well understood.
- An individual or partnership buyer buying 80% or more: a 336(e).
- Private equity, a partial purchase, rollover equity, or any doubt about the S election: an F reorganization.
- A C corporation owned by individuals: none of these gives a step-up without a corporate-level tax. That calls for different planning.
- An individual buying with an SBA 7(a) loan: the buyer isn't a corporation, so a 338(h)(10) is off the table. Most of these deals are asset purchases, and the price allocation decides the buyer's deductions. See the SBA Playbook.
Where our books go deeper
Buyers, sellers and their advisors ask this question in almost every deal, so the Institute's guides cover it in full:
- The Practitioner's Guide to Private Equity: deal structuring and tax, including the F reorganization, the 336(e) and 338(h)(10) elections, rollover equity and purchase price allocation.
- M&A Advisory, Decoded: the sale process from the seller's side, the purchase agreement and the closing.
- The CFO and Controller guide: quality of earnings and buying a company.
All titles are available at baratelliinstitute.com.
How to work with the firm
Baratelli Transaction Advisory and Baratelli CPA & Accounting help buyers and sellers model a deal after tax, with quality of earnings, purchase price allocation and the returns that follow.
Call (561) 228-6123 Quality of Earnings The SBA PlaybookThis article is general education, not tax or legal advice for a specific transaction. Every deal turns on its facts; buyers and sellers should consult their own advisors before choosing a structure.